Science Guardian

Paradigms and power in science and society

I am Nicolaus Copernicus, and I approve of this blog

I am Richard Feynman and I approve of this blogComparing mainstream claims in science and technology and received wisdom in society with the published record, we defend honest, accomplished, independent minded and often heroic scientists (Peter Duesberg, Serge Lang, Harvey Bialy, Kary Mullis, Henry Bauer, Jim Watson, Peter Medawar, Erwin Chargaff, Richard Feynman, Linus Pauling, James Hansen, Fred Singer, Richard Lindzer, Rainer Plaga, Otto Rossler, Michio Kaku, David Rasnick, Rebecca Culshaw, Ernst Krebs, Mark Leggett, Adrian Kent) and their good science against the censorship, mudslinging, false arguments, ad hominem propaganda, overwhelming group prejudice and internal science politics of the paradigm wars of cancer, HIV/AIDS, evolution, global warming, collider physics, health, medicine and nutrition, as well as from time to time promoting truth in personal technology by identifying items of genuinely high quality from those whose reputation is unjustly magnified in the media.

I am Galileo Galilei, and I approve of this blog, but wish to warn the author that it is unwise to get on the wrong side of the Pope by portraying him as a simpleton, as I did, although confinement to my villa wasn't too bad a punishment.I am Bertrand Russell and I approve of this blog for three reasons - because it is for science, because it is against against religion, and because it is especially against religious belief in any scientific paradigm. This publication aims to measure truth only by the professional and scholarly literature in peer reviewed journals, well researched books, and the investigative reporting and reviews of thoughtful and informed if often unconventional academics, philosophers, researchers, scholars, authors, and journalists (John Lauritsen, Celia Farber, Liam Scheff, Robert Houston, Claus Jensen, Anthony Liversidge, James Blodgett, Jim Tankersley, John Tierney, Bob Herbert, Dennis Overbye, Marcus Cohen, Gary Null, Walter Wagner, Luis Sancho, Toby Ord and Eric Johnson) too often scorned, shortchanged or damned by publicly irresponsible scientists and other authorities living off the status quo.

Thus we hope to combat the influence of the running dog lackeys of those in power who mislead in science and society, namely compliant media editors, unquestioning science reporters, ignorant publishers, fellow traveling pharma activists and other invested parties, and their misled congregation of patients, doctors, politicians, officials, charity workers, foundation staff, celebrities, bloggers and innocent members of the confused but trusting general public who may assume that leading scientists and other gurus are not subject to the laws of human nature, by which personal rewards and group goals can trump professional conscience and the public interest.

I am Carl Sagan, and I approve of this blog, because it encourages the lay person to practice the scientific method for himself,  and to double check the verbal claims of scientists, however prominent, against the published literature and common sense.  I myself wish that I had been less gullible when I was alive, for then I would not have taken the AIDS HIV claim at face value, and I might have saved myself from standard treatment for leukemia.   After all, I did stand up for marijuana and against the political prejudice and legal suppression which prevents all of us benefiting from its educational influence.I am Freeman Dyson, and I approve of this blog, but would warn the author that life as a heretic is a hard one, since the ignorant and the half informed, let alone those who should know better, will automatically trash their betters who try to enlighten them with independent thinking, as I have found to my sorrow in commenting on "global warming" and its cures. I have never made but one prayer to God, a very short one: “O Lord make my enemies ridiculous.” And God granted it. – Voltaire

Everything that one thinks about a lot becomes problematic. – Friedrich Nietzsche

A little inaccuracy sometimes saves tons of explanation. – Saki (H. H. Munro).

More Quotations on Science and Belief

Best viewed ONLY in LARGE font in current Safari or Firefox in Mac, and Firefox or Chrome in PC (IE displays all text bold). Display a single post and its comments for printout by clicking on its headline (printout won't include the scurrilous remarks appended to images which are briefly visible if the cursor is placed over them, repeat if necessary). All posts guaranteed fact checked according to reference level cited. Guide to blog purpose and layout is in the other blue section at the bottom of every home page.

(Incorporating New AIDS Review)

Blood money saves nurses

Libyan medical hostages saved by $1 million per family payout

EU, US, Bulgaria and Libya fund $460 million jackpot

montagnier.jpegLuc Montagnier can breathe easier now, along with many around the world who were concerned that the eight years of prison, rape and torture inflicted on five Bulgarian nurses and an Egyptian doctor in Libya would end in execution, as ordained by the Libyan Supreme Court.

A promise of $1 million per family has been made to the parents of the babies supposedly somehow infected by HIV at the Tripoli hospital, and this has been accepted as sufficient blood money to allow them to relent and be satisfied with a different outcome.

Reuters reports that the nurses can expect to be released from their torment soon by the Judicial Panel, now that the Libyan lynch mob has been paid off.

The payout is expected to bring to a close the eight-year legal case surrounding the medics and the children and remove a major obstacle to Libyan leader Muammar Gaddafi’s return to the international stage after decades of diplomatic isolation.

montagnier3.jpegMontagnier is now released from the obligation of finally confessing that he, the half hearted originator of the global scientific fantasy launched by his rival Robert Gallo on the world in 1984, doesn’t really believe in it. This might have been the only way in which the lives of the nurses and doctor could have been saved, if the nearly half billion dollar payout hadn’t become available.

Unlikely as that may seem, we have sufficient confidence in Montagnier as the only leader of the political movement for HIV∫AIDS paradigm promulgation, protection and prevention of review to possess any gentlemanly qualities whatsoever that he might have considered abandoning the whole project with the lives of innocent men and women at stake.

Unlike the many millions of gays and black and brown people in Africa and Asia who have been and will be victims of the gross miscarriage of science with which Montagnier has been a half hearted fellow traveler. these six had faces, and their predicament was unjustified even by the false assumptions of standard HIV∫AIDS thinking that Montagnier has gone along with so skittishly for so long.

montagnier4.pngMontagnier was brave and decent enough to go to Tripoli and ascertain that the conditions in the city’s hospitals are so unhygienic that the motives of officials in scapegoating the Bulgarians became very clear, and he was willing to say so. It seems just possible that as the unfortunate group approached the Libya execution chamber that Montagnier, who in our opinion judging from his gourmand features is a lot more interested in the good life than he is in hurting people, would have broken down and confessed.

montagnier1.jpegNow we shall never know, and indeed, the story will probably have the opposite effect, confirming the validity of HIV∫AIDS paradigm in the minds of millions more people around the world, who might otherwise have doubted it for the many conflicting claims inherent in the ideology which so flout common sense. The chief of these of course is a pandemic based on a condition of possessing HIV antibodies which cannot be transmitted between the sexes at a rate faster than 1 in 1000, if at all, as Nancy Padian’s research has confirmed.

After all, a paradigm that can sustain eight years of torture of innocent nurses, at least three of whom are very pretty, and a payout of nearly half a billion dollars, must be valid.

Mustn’t it?

Families receive settlement in Libya HIV nurses case:
Families receive settlement in Libya HIV nurses case
Tue Jul 17, 2007 7:07PM BST
By Salah Sarrar

TRIPOLI (Reuters) – The families of hundreds of HIV positive children in Libya received a $460 million (230 million pound) financial settlement on Tuesday, opening the door for a judicial panel to free six foreign medics condemned to death for infecting them.

The payout is expected to bring to a close the eight-year legal case surrounding the medics and the children and remove a major obstacle to Libyan leader Muammar Gaddafi’s return to the international stage after decades of diplomatic isolation.

The medics — five Bulgarian nurses and a Palestinian doctor — were sentenced to death last year after being convicted of intentionally starting an HIV epidemic at a children’s hospital in the city of Benghazi. They say they are innocent.

Spokesman Idriss Lagha said 460 families in all had received “compensation money”, each family receiving $1.0 million.

He would not comment on speculation they would send a declaration to Libya’s High Judicial Council renouncing the medics’ death sentences but said the way appeared open for a pardon.

“They did not say they had pardoned the medics, but my personal interpretation is that their move is the equivalent of a pardon because the compensation money is the equivalent in Islam to ‘blood money’, which entails pardon,” he said.

In jail since 1999, the medics say they are innocent and confessions central to their case were extracted under torture.

Foreign HIV experts say the infections started before the workers arrived at the hospital and are more likely to be the result of poor hygiene.

The victims’ families have said the case was part of a Western attempt to undermine Muslims and Libya. Fifty-six of the children have died, which has provoked widespread anger in Libya over their suffering.

RULING EXPECTED

The High Judicial Council, which has the power to commute sentences or issue pardons, took over the case last week after Libya’s Supreme Court upheld the death sentences.

The Council has held off on ruling on the fate of the medics pending the families’ acceptance of the deal with the European Union, which has campaigned on behalf of its new member Bulgaria to have the nurses freed and sent home.

Benita Ferrero-Waldner, EU commissioner for external relations, welcomed the families’ acceptance of the settlement.

“This is indeed good news,” she said.

“We trust that this should now permit the High Judicial Council to take a decision in favour of the Bulgarian nurses and the Palestinian doctor.” She added that the Union would continue to stand by commitments to assist the HIV infected children.

Lagha said many sources had contributed: “The money came from the Benghazi International Fund, which is financed by the European Union, United States, Bulgaria and Libya.”

He said the documents signed by the families would be taken to the judicial council later on Tuesday, and Othman Bizanti, a leading lawyer for the nurses, said he had “great hope” that the council would free the medics.

Bulgaria and its allies in the EU and the United States say Libya is using the medics as scapegoats to deflect criticism from a dilapidated health care sector.

They have also suggested that not freeing the nurses would hurt Gaddafi’s efforts to emerge from isolation, a process he began by scrapping a prohibited weapons programme in 2003.
© Reuters 2006.

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.


Bad Behavior has blocked 1093 access attempts in the last 7 days.