Science Guardian

Paradigms and power in science and society

I am Nicolaus Copernicus, and I approve of this blog

I am Richard Feynman and I approve of this blogComparing mainstream claims in science and technology and received wisdom in society with the published record, we defend honest, accomplished, independent minded and often heroic scientists (Peter Duesberg, Serge Lang, Harvey Bialy, Kary Mullis, Henry Bauer, Jim Watson, Peter Medawar, Erwin Chargaff, Richard Feynman, Linus Pauling, James Hansen, Fred Singer, Richard Lindzer, Rainer Plaga, Otto Rossler, Michio Kaku, David Rasnick, Rebecca Culshaw, Ernst Krebs, Mark Leggett, Adrian Kent) and their good science against the censorship, mudslinging, false arguments, ad hominem propaganda, overwhelming group prejudice and internal science politics of the paradigm wars of cancer, HIV/AIDS, evolution, global warming, collider physics, health, medicine and nutrition, as well as from time to time promoting truth in personal technology by celebrating items of genuinely high quality from those overpromoted in the media.

I am Galileo Galilei, and I approve of this blog, but wish to warn the author that it is unwise to get on the wrong side of the Pope by portraying him as a simpleton, as I did, although confinement to my villa wasn't too bad a punishment.I am Bertrand Russell and I approve of this blog for three reasons - because it is for science, because it is against against religion, and because it is especially against religious belief in any scientific paradigm. Here we measure truth only by the professional and scholarly literature in peer reviewed journals, well researched books, and the investigative reporting and reviews of well informed original thinkers among academics, philosophers, researchers, scholars, authors, and journalists (John Lauritsen, Celia Farber, Liam Scheff, Robert Houston, Claus Jensen, Anthony Liversidge, James Blodgett, Jim Tankersley, John Tierney, Bob Herbert, Dennis Overbye, Marcus Cohen, Gary Null, Walter Wagner, Luis Sancho, Toby Ord and Eric Johnson) too often scorned, shortchanged or damned by publicly irresponsible scientists and other authorities living off the status quo.

Thus we hope to combat the influence of the running dog lackeys of those in power who mislead us in science and society, namely compliant media editors, unquestioning science reporters, ignorant publishers, fellow traveling pharma activists and other invested parties, and their misled congregation of patients, doctors, politicians, officials, charity workers, foundation staff, celebrities, bloggers and innocent members of the confused but trusting general public who may naively assume that leading scientists and other gurus are not subject to the laws of human nature, by which personal rewards and group goals can trump professional conscience and the public interest.

I am Carl Sagan, and I approve of this blog, because it encourages the lay person to practice the scientific method for himself,  and to double check the verbal claims of scientists, however prominent, against the published literature and common sense.  I myself wish that I had been less gullible when I was alive, for then I would not have taken the AIDS HIV claim at face value, and I might have saved myself from standard treatment for leukemia.   After all, I did stand up for marijuana and against the political prejudice and legal suppression which prevents all of us benefiting from its educational influence.I am Freeman Dyson, and I approve of this blog, but would warn the author that life as a heretic is a hard one, since the ignorant and the half informed, let alone those who should know better, will automatically trash their betters who try to enlighten them with independent thinking, as I have found to my sorrow in commenting on "global warming" and its cures. I have never made but one prayer to God, a very short one: “O Lord make my enemies ridiculous.” And God granted it. – Voltaire

Everything that one thinks about a lot becomes problematic. – Friedrich Nietzsche

A little inaccuracy sometimes saves tons of explanation. – Saki (H. H. Munro).

More Quotations on Science and Belief

Best viewed ONLY in LARGE font in current Safari or Firefox in Mac, and Firefox or Chrome in PC (IE displays all text bold). Display a single post and its comments for printout by clicking on its headline (printout won't include the scurrilous remarks appended to images which are briefly visible if the cursor is placed over them, repeat if necessary). All posts guaranteed fact checked according to reference level cited. Guide to blog purpose and layout is in the other blue section at the bottom of every home page.

(Incorporating New AIDS Review)

Times conveys HIV superstition as reality in Vietnam


Visibly healthy mother under “death sentence”, according to the world’s most responsible HIV?AIDS daily

Anyone fully informed about the Grand Canyon now opened between conventional wisdom and scientific reality in HIV?AIDS must be sickened by the New York Times’ record in this affair, the worst tendencies of which are encapsulated in the page three story today (Sun May 28), Shunned, Women With H.I.V. Join Forces in Vietnam, concerning the hapless women “with HIV” in Vietnam.

Given that the Times has access to the highest sources of any kind, and employs the most intelligent and worldly reporters, there is no excuse left for profoundly misleading its readers on a major health policy topic, which is a matter of life and death for many.

Look at this photo, and consider how healthy the beautiful young mother and child “with HIV” evidently are, and how the Times’ reporting reflects nothing of the mainstream science of the last few years (that scotches any possibility that HIV is conveyed by husbands to wives), let alone the twenty years of authoritative, credentialed, unremitting, unanswered, massively referenced, peer reviewed, elite rejection of this irrational and incredible paradigm.

Ms. Hue, 26, who was infected by her husband, a drug addict, was one of the first to speak out publicly on television “to show that we are people, too.” The support group she founded three years ago — called Haiphong Red Flamboyant, for the name of a flower — is expanding in this city and is a model for similar groups around the country.

What the women rarely talk about, except when they are joking, is the near-certainty that in time they, too, will fall ill and that they will be feeding, bathing and consoling one another, and caring for one another’s children, as one by one they die.

With the science desk in thrall to the NIH, and the general news reporters guided by the science desk, and the foreign reporters in the hands of UNAIDS as here, the appalling record of the Times over the last two decades looks likely to continue forever, until something happens outside its walls to change its mantra from “HIV the virus that causes AIDS” to at the very least, “HIV, the virus believed to cause AIDS”.

Anything less than that and the newspaper will have to take blame for many more deaths as it continues to purvey the conventional wisdom as if it was validated by the literature, when it is in fact thoroughly debunked in major respects even in mainstream papers now.

(show)

The New York Times

Printer Friendly Format Sponsored By

May 28, 2006

Shunned, Women With H.I.V. Join Forces in Vietnam

By SETH MYDANS

By SETH MYDANS

HAIPHONG, Vietnam — The neighbors know what is going on when they hear peals of laughter coming from the house of Pham Thi Hue. The dying women have gotten together again.

Crammed onto a couch and little chairs, the women shout and clap as they talk about the city’s shortage of shrouds or about the dying man with the bloated stomach who slept under a bridge.

They are members of a support group for people infected with H.I.V. in a society where they are widely shunned, where drugs are scarce and treatment is expensive and where a diagnosis of infection is still, for most people, a sentence of death.

They gathered on a recent Saturday in this big port city near Hanoi, 15 women — many of whom had not told their families they were infected — sharing companionship and the relief of laughter from lives of poverty, illness and dread.

In the face of discrimination and in the absence of adequate health care, they are for the most part one another’s only support.

This is a country teetering on the brink of a nationwide epidemic, with more than 250,000 people infected with the virus that causes AIDS and with only 10 percent of those who fall ill receiving the treatment they need, according to Unaids, the United Nations agency.

The country’s health care system is well organized, but the disease has until now been concentrated among intravenous drug users and has not been treated as a priority. Experts say it is beginning to spread quickly into the broader population, and one of the chief barriers to prevention and treatment is the stigma that makes outcasts of those who carry the virus.

Ms. Hue, 26, who was infected by her husband, a drug addict, was one of the first to speak out publicly on television “to show that we are people, too.” The support group she founded three years ago — called Haiphong Red Flamboyant, for the name of a flower — is expanding in this city and is a model for similar groups around the country.

What the women rarely talk about, except when they are joking, is the near-certainty that in time they, too, will fall ill and that they will be feeding, bathing and consoling one another, and caring for one another’s children, as one by one they die.

“The meaning of the group,” said Nguyen Thi Sau, 29, whose husband has already died from AIDS complications, “is so that when you die you are less lonely.”

In what they say is a form of therapy, the women have chosen to look directly into the face of the suffering that lies ahead, nursing, cleaning and feeding the sick, collecting the bodies of people who die alone in hospitals or on the streets and attending the funerals of those whose families have turned their backs.

“Some days I have to take care of four people who have died in the hospital,” said Ms. Sau, who worked at a shoe factory until she was fired. A number of the patients, she said, are prisoners who have been sent to the hospital to die, covered in their own filth and still chained to their cots.

“I’m the one who has to close their eyes when they die,” she said. “After that I can’t sleep at night.”

Over the past three years scores of women have been members of Red Flamboyant. Many have died, but the group has only grown — and spawned new groups — as more infected women step from the shadows and join.

Most of the women gathered that Saturday said they had been infected by their husbands here in a city where drug addiction is widespread, and most said their husbands had already died. All had lost their jobs when their employers discovered that they were infected.

Ms. Hue’s husband is now in the late stages of the disease in a drug-rehabilitation center. She lost her work as a tailor and he lost his job as a cook in a hotel when their infections became known.

She now works with the local Communist Party women’s union to expand support groups through the city, and she receives small grants from foreign aid organizations. The money is used to help members with emergencies and to distribute rice to people who have fallen ill and no longer have an income.

Support groups like this are an important part of the government’s strategy to combat the disease, said Nancy Fee, the country coordinator for Unaids.

The government is preparing new legislation now to combat the epidemic, some $50 million in assistance is arriving from abroad, and more drugs are becoming available, Ms. Fee said.

“But they still have to train a lot of health workers and set up the systems and protocols and they need a public information campaign,” she said. “That work is happening and it does need to speed up, it does need more of a sense of urgency.”

When the husband of Nguyen Thi Kim Van, 36, fell ill, Red Flamboyant bought him a small bed so he could sleep separately from his family, which was crowded together in his parents’ tiny home.

When he died, his parents evicted Ms. Van, and she took her three children to live in her mother’s even tinier home, where all five of them now sleep on one bed.

Ms. Van, who is H.I.V.-positive, tries to support her family by selling small cups of tea on the sidewalk; Red Flamboyant gives her rice and money to send her oldest son to school.

At the same time, she has become an active member of the group, and it was she who crawled under the bridge to try to help the man with the bloated stomach. He was aggressive and frightening, she said, miming the scene, and she just jumped up and ran away.

“Did you touch his belly?” her friends shouted, laughing. “You were trying to take advantage of him, weren’t you!”

Not long after her visit to the bridge, someone took a photograph of the man, but his face is not visible in the picture. He is lying on the ground covered with a shroud, one of the bodies the group has collected for burial.

On this Saturday, the photograph lay forgotten among the teacups on a small table. Ms. Hue’s 5-year-old son, Ha Minh Hieu, who is not infected, spent some time examining it.

As the afternoon passed, Ms. Sau, who had spent the morning cleaning and feeding an AIDS patient, leaned her head on the shoulder of a friend, Doan Thi Khuyen, 23, and they sang quietly together.

Ms. Khuyen, a former secretary, was dressed in a crisp white blouse with careful makeup and stylish hair, as if she were heading to the office.

But she was fired from her job months ago because of her illness, and she now sells lottery tickets on the street to support herself and her small child, who is also infected.

“I wanted to be a shoeshine girl, but all they have is shoeshine boys,” she moaned, and everyone laughed.

“Well,” said Ms. Hue, “at least you’re alive. You’re not dead yet.”

That seemed to strike the women as funny too, and they laughed again.

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.


Bad Behavior has blocked 797 access attempts in the last 7 days.